Max Scherzer's 3,000th strikeout highlights MLB's gentle obsession with round-number statistics

Max Scherzer grew to become the nineteenth member of the three,000-strikeout membership on Sunday, and he did so in classic Scherzer vogue. 

Eric Hosmer, like so many Scherzer strikeout victims, appeared like he had no probability when swinging at Scherzer’s 88 mph changeup. However the truth that the ever-intense future Corridor of Famer appeared aggravated that he needed to acknowledge the accomplishment within the second as a result of it meant he needed to cease mowing down Padres hitters in a sport that mattered within the standings? 

That’s so Max. 

MORE: 10 single-season MLB feats we’ll by no means see once more

We’ve had a run of great round-number MLB milestones currently. Joey Votto recorded his 2,000th hit on Aug. 16, a line-drive single to middle discipline. Miguel Cabrera hit his five hundredth house run, an opposite-field shot — what else? — on Aug. 22. Now, Scherzer at 3,000.

Greater than some other sport, these spherical numbers maintain significance in baseball.

“These are iconic numbers, the 100 RBIs, hitting .300, the five hundred homers,” former Braves slugger Dale Murphy mentioned. “I do not know if there are iconic numbers like that in different sports activities which have transcended the historical past of the sport.” 

Ought to it matter if a man like Murphy finishes at 398 house runs as an alternative of 400? No, not likely. It’s no completely different than Mike Piazza ending at 425 as an alternative of his precise whole of 427. The distinction remains to be simply two homers.

However, yeah, it issues. Corridor of Famer Frank Thomas completed with a .301 profession batting common, to go along with his 521 homers and 1,704 RBIs. I requested him not too long ago whether or not it could have mattered to him if he had, let’s say, completed at .299 as an alternative of .301.

“It could have mattered, sure,” he mentioned, barely letting me end my query. “That was a objective of mine. … Meaning loads. To perform that, to get to 500 homers, as a man who hits .300, that is very particular. Not a whole lot of guys have accomplished that.”

MORE: The newest no-hitter for each MLB crew

There’s a purpose Ted Williams is praised for enjoying on the ultimate day of the 1941 season when his .3996 batting common technically would have counted as a .400 common. There’s a purpose John Kruk instantly retired after his first-inning single on July 30, 1995, left his profession batting common at precisely .300. He actually showered and left the sport, by no means to play once more, at 34 years previous. 

Perhaps spherical numbers shouldn’t matter a lot, however they do. And it is not simply the historic spherical numbers, like 500 homers or 3,000 strikeouts. Each spherical quantity has a little bit of significance. Heck, Baseball-Reference has a milestone tracker for this precise purpose. 

“Yeah, I imply there is a huge distinction between having an ERA or 2.95 or 3.05, or within the 3s as an alternative of the 4s,” former No. 1 total decide Andy Benes informed SN. “As you get nearer to the tip of the profession …

That “on reflection” is a theme for gamers.

“I look again on it completely different now,” former Angels slugger Tim Salmon mentioned. “As a participant, I downplayed every part. Simply play, assist the crew win and transfer on. No matter. However in hindsight, you have a look at issues and the way completely different would have been if I’d paid extra consideration to issues.”

Murphy, Salmon and Benes completed their careers perpetually tied to spherical numbers, good and unhealthy. Let’s have a look at their tales. 

Dale Murphy, 398 profession house runs

Murphy completed two house runs shy of the 400 mark for his profession, and he’s requested about it just about each time he chats with baseball followers. It’s within the query rotation together with “Why did you select No. 3?” And “What’s your favourite second of your profession?” 

He is likely to be the nicest particular person ever to play baseball, so he solutions every part with a smile. However, yeah, he has ideas with regards to spherical numbers and baseball. 

“It actually is not only a baseball factor. It is human psychology,” he mentioned. “It’s left-digit bias. There’s an actual psychology to it. Take a look at the pricing in retail. Completely, no query. … Left-digit bias is you learn from left to proper, and once you see 299 versus 300, you assume it is loads much less, since you see the 2 and evaluate it to the three.”

He’s not flawed. Left-digit bias is why a field of family-sized Triscuits are $3.99 and never $4.00. It’s why a blaster of 2021 Topps Baseball playing cards is $19.99 at Walmart and never $20. It’s why that used automobile has an enormous $9,995 sticker and never a cleaner $10K tag. It is a actual, documented factor.

“I do not need to downplay the truth that I want I had 400, you recognize,” Murphy mentioned with fun. “I’m like everybody else. I needed to hit .300. I needed 100 RBIs. I perceive the psychology. I get it.”

That 398 house run whole is a puzzle with two little items lacking. It simply appears to be like incomplete. Murphy appears to be like at one other up to date of his and sees the quantity 493 — Fred McGriff’s profession home-run whole. Simply seven in need of that iconic 500 quantity. Like Murphy, he’s on the surface trying in on the Corridor of Fame.

“In Fred’s case, the 4 appears to be like loads completely different than 5,” Murphy mentioned. “It’s simply psychological. Folks have mentioned, ‘He by no means gained an MVP’ or no matter, however for instance he received 500 house runs. What would maintain him out?”

It’s laborious not to take a look at baseball’s labor stoppages for each Murphy and McGriff. Murphy performed in 104 of Atlanta’s 106 video games in 1981 and hit 13 homers. Would he have hit two extra if the Braves didn’t lose 56 video games to the strike? Yeah, nearly definitely.

And McGriff performed 257 of Atlanta’s 258 video games in 1994 and 1995, the seasons impacted by that labor stoppage. He had 34 homers in 113 video games in ’94 and 27 in ’95. Would he have hit seven extra house runs within the 67 video games the Braves misplaced to the strike? Yeah, nearly definitely. 

As soon as upon a time, Murphy appeared he would attain the 500-homer mark, and that 400 plateau can be a facet be aware alongside the best way. Murphy had his first 20-plus homer yr in his Age 22 season, 1978. He gained back-to-back NL MVP awards in 1982 and 1983, then led the NL in homers in 1984 and 1985. His totals these 4 seasons: 36, 36, 36, 37. He hit 29 in 1986 after which a career-high 44 in 1987, his Age 31 season. He was at 310 homers. 

Murphy hit 86 over the subsequent 4 years, cut up between Atlanta and Philadelphia. Knee points that had zapped his energy restricted him to 18 video games and two homers in 1992, and Murphy signed with the Rockies in April 1993, after the Phillies reduce ties on the finish of spring coaching. What higher place than the skinny air of Denver to get these final two homers? 

It didn’t occur. Murphy was principally a pinch-hitter. He performed in 26 video games with 11 begins and went 6-for-42 with one extra-base hit, a double. He retired on Could 27, 1993. 

“Why did not I keep on for 400? There’s numerous explanation why I didn’t,” Murphy mentioned. “I wasn’t enjoying that effectively. No person known as from the American League and mentioned, ‘We might love so that you can DH.’ I wasn’t that wholesome both, with the Rockies. 

“At that time in my profession I simply could not chase two extra. Nancy was anticipating our eighth youngster, so there have been different points, too.” 

What about these two lacking house runs? There are two Murphy thinks about. One was a house run he hit towards Sid Fernandez, a sport that was rained out (it doesn’t present up on Retrosheet’s listing of rained-out homers, however that’s an admittedly incomplete listing). After which, there was one an unlikely outfielder stole. 

“Jack Clark did not rob a whole lot of house runs, however I particularly have a reminiscence of him,” Murphy mentioned. “We had a decrease fence within the early Eighties in Atlanta, and I’ve a selected reminiscence of it. I do not keep in mind the main points, besides the truth that it was Jack Clark who robbed me. I can image him going again and getting it.”

However the rain and Clark meant Murphy ended his 18-year profession with 398 homers.

“It appears to be like like 100 lower than 400, proper, moderately than two much less” he mentioned with one other chuckle. “That is simply the best way we’re.”

Andy Benes, 2,000 profession strikeouts

Andy Benes was the No. 1 total decide within the 1988 MLB Draft and he threw the very first regular-season pitch in Arizona Diamondbacks historical past, in 1998. Keep in mind essentially the most well-known sport in Mariners historical past, when Ken Griffey Jr. dashed all the best way across the bases to attain the profitable run and beat the Yankees in Sport 5 of the 1995 ALDS? Benes began that contest for the Mariners.

He led the NL in strikeouts in 1994 and completed top-six within the Cy Younger voting twice; the primary 13 years of his huge league profession have been stuffed with highlights, and a few lowlights, too.

However even he couldn’t have predicted what that 14th yr, the 2002 season, had in retailer for him. Heading into that season, his Age 34 yr, Benes had misplaced about 13 mph off his peak triple-digit fastball, the results of knee points that left him unable to drive off the mound. His lone 2000 playoff begin for the Cardinals was a gem of confusion and misdirection; he pitched eight innings towards the Mets and informed Sporting Information that not a single pitch registered above 83 mph. 

That system caught the Mets off-guard in October, however it was a catastrophe in 2001, when he completed with a 7.38 ERA in 107 1/3 innings. He went into spring coaching 2002 with a mid-80s fastball and, for the primary time in his profession, no ensures of even a roster spot, a lot much less a rotation spot. He earned a job as a starter, however it didn’t final lengthy. His first three begins resulted in solely 10 whole innings, 17 hits, 12 walks, 5 strikeouts and a ten.80 ERA. 

The Cardinals, principally, despatched him house. He was 59 strikeouts away from 2,000, and it appeared like he’d by no means get there. 

After a few weeks, he reached out to Cardinals GM Walt Jocketty to let him know he’d been engaged on a number of issues and needed to present it one other shot. The Cardinals have been good that yr, however their rotation was a multitude, when it comes to well being; eight completely different pitchers began video games for the membership in Could. Nonetheless, the decision Benes was ready for didn’t come instantly. 

Lastly, per week or so later, Jocketty known as again. 

”Hey, how are you doing?” Jocketty mentioned. “What are you doing?”

“I’m pitching,” Benes replied. 



“Who’re you pitching to?”

“My 6-year-old’s pee-wee crew.” 

“Properly, good. I am calling as a result of we would like you to start out figuring out. I do have one query for you, although.”

“Positive, what’s it?”

“Are you getting them out?” 

Benes laughed.

“Properly, these guys are fairly powerful. Some, sure, some I am not.”

MORE: Yadier Molina’s Corridor of Fame case is not sophisticated for individuals who competed with him

So the Cardinals had Benes ramp issues again up, and a part of that course of included a cease in Memphis, house of the crew’s Triple-A membership. There, Benes was assigned No. 57, the identical quantity as his pal Darryl Kile, who wore No. 57 for the large league Cardinals. Unusual, proper? However not a giant deal. Benes was scheduled to start out for Memphis on June 22, and he was sitting in his lodge room that afternoon. 

He flipped on the Cardinals-Cubs sport.

You recognize what occurred that day. There was no sport. Kile died in his lodge room, at 33 years previous. 

“I used to be buddies with DK,” Benes mentioned. “We have been teammates for years. I used to be identical to, ‘OK, I do know I will end the yr for him.’ Mentally, I used to be able to go. I used to be throwing the ball fairly effectively, and my perspective was completely completely different.”

Benes returned to the Cardinals for the second half of the season, with a brand new goal and a brand new pitch. Keen to attempt something at this level, he’d picked up a splitter for the primary time in his profession. The primary time he used it in a giant league sport, it helped him escape a bases-loaded, no-outs state of affairs. 

“I used to be throwing my finest stuff they usually had the bases loaded, so I figured what the heck?” Benes mentioned. “I used to be simply letting it flying, attempting to be unpredictable.”

Benes was sensible. He made 14 begins and one reduction look within the second half, racking up a 1.86 ERA. Benes received the beginning within the ultimate sport of the season, which mattered for potential playoff home-field within the NLDS, regardless that they’d lengthy since wrapped up the NL Central title. Benes began the sport at 1,998 profession strikeouts. 

Ryan Christianson, the leadoff batter, went down swinging, on a strike-to-ball slider that had resulted in a lot of swings and misses over his profession. Another left. Straightforward, proper? 

Benes was rolling by way of the Milwaukee lineup, however he didn’t register a strikeout within the second, third or fourth, regardless of attending to two-strike counts on 5 hitters. His again was beginning to tighten up. With two outs within the fifth and sport tied, 0-0, Christianson was up once more, with Paul Bako on first. Benes jumped forward with an 0-2 rely, however three straight out of the zone left the rely at 3-2. 

The sixth pitch was over the plate, a known as Strike Three. Mike Matheny, the catcher, threw out Bako attempting to steal, a basic strike-em-out, throw-em-out double play. The scoreboard at Busch Stadium made certain everybody within the ballpark knew concerning the milestone Benes had simply reached. 

“It was emotional for me, as a result of I used to be a kind of followers for a very long time, sitting in these seats up within the higher deck,” Benes mentioned. “I grew up an enormous Cardinals fan and would come over to St. Louis from southern Indiana in the course of the ’80s once I was in highschool and watch video games. I simply at all times cherished the Cardinals, they have been my crew. So to have that at Busch Stadium, it was the final day, bought out with a standing ovation, that was actually cool.”

Seems, that 3-2 strike to Christianson was the final regular-season pitch Benes ever threw. He made two postseason begins that yr, then retired quickly after the season.

After the struggles of the previous couple of seasons, going out with a great style in his mouth was vital.

“Simply to get to that quantity was actually, actually particular,” Benes mentioned. “It put me within the high 75 all time on the time, or someplace like that. It is simply higher than one in need of that. I imply, I had a whole lot of guys with two strikes they usually put the ball in play. On the finish of the day, I felt very blessed to get to that quantity. 

“It is distinctive. There usually are not too many who finish proper on the quantity.”

Tim Salmon, 299 profession house runs

Till accidents took their toll, Tim Salmon was one of the crucial dependable hitters in baseball. From 1993 to 2000, Salmon reached the 30-home run mark 5 instances and averaged 28 homers and 94 RBIs, with a .294/.396/.532 slash line, a 138 OPS+ and a 4.0 bWAR. 

However accidents did take their toll, affecting his means to remain productive and on the sector. Lastly, in late August 2004 — proper round his thirty sixth birthday — Salmon shut it down. He had two main surgical procedures, on the rotator cuff of his left shoulder and microfracture surgical procedure on his left knee. The rehab course of can be lengthy and tough, and he knew that is likely to be the tip of his enjoying profession. He had 290 house runs.

“The 290 by no means resonated as a result of it was simply 290,” he informed SN. “If it had been 490, it could have been a totally completely different story. Perhaps even 390. It simply wasn’t on my radar.”

Salmon threw himself into the rehab course of for 17 months. Properly, into rehab and Little League, the place he was “elbow deep” working along with his children. He reported to spring coaching in 2006 principally as a method to wrap up the rehab course of. 

“I used to be absolutely anticipating that will be my farewell. I’d retire,” Salmon mentioned. “However I got here again and didn’t really feel ache doing the issues I’d turn out to be accustomed to. That was thrilling, to not really feel ache. I used to be enjoying first rate, swinging the bat decently and we had a bunch of fellows that received damage. Another yr I wouldn’t have gotten the reps within the video games to know what I’d be capable of do. It was due to these circumstances that I used to be getting reps within the video games. I used to be actually proving it to myself.”

Salmon homered in his second plate look of the common season, and once more in his fourth. He didn’t play each day, principally sharing DH duties with outfielders Garrett Anderson and Vladimir Guerrero (Sr.). He was rolling together with a .866 OPS and 6 homers in 164 PAs by way of the tip of June. 

On Sept. 28, having confirmed every part he needed to show after his rehab and return to the large leagues, he formally introduced that he was retiring after the season. He was at 299 house runs, having hit that one the evening earlier than, off Rangers starter Adam Eaton. 

“I imply, it enters my thoughts from the standpoint of, ‘I’m going to play tomorrow, it could be good to hit it.’ However nothing from the standpoint of, ‘I’m coming again to get it.’ At that time of the yr, you’re drained,” he mentioned. “My knee, I’ve an arthritic knee and I knew what it took to take care of it. It’s simply not value it. I need to have an energetic retirement. It simply didn’t appear that vital, to get that another house run.”

Salmon began every of the Angels’ 4 ultimate video games, however didn’t get one out of the ballpark. If you recognize something about Tim Salmon, the particular person, you recognize he’s turned this right into a constructive. 

“I’ll say this, and I’ve at all times mentioned it, to me, 299 is nice! If I’d gotten to 301, no one would ever blink an eye fixed,” he mentioned. “However 299, all people asks me about it. I get much more mileage out of it, and it’s enjoyable to speak about. I at all times say that if I used to be at 499, heck yeah, roll me out in a wheelchair. I’m enjoying till I get it. Even if you happen to’re above 450, heck yeah, you play as a few years as you’ll be able to to get to it, as a result of 500 is the magical quantity. However round 300, I used to be so distant from it, it simply wasn’t going to occur.”

On one hand, it is kinda loopy to assume that, in an impressive profession that spanned 14 seasons, 1,672 video games and seven,039 plate appearances, perhaps another ball might have slipped over the wall. Salmon is aware of the place a few potentials ended, although. 

“By the best way, Kenny Lofton stole two or three from me,” Salmon mentioned with fun. “I gotta thank Kenny Lofton for conserving me on the 299 mark.”

Leave a reply