Bryce Harper hype practice is leaving the station, however is he actually the NL MVP favourite?

The e-mail from an oddsmaker popped into my inbox at 12:34 p.m. CT on Monday afternoon, in regards to the quickly altering NL East, and the way the Mets’ collapse — timed towards the rise of the Phillies and Braves — has flipped, turned upside-down a once-boring division. 

At No. 10 on an inventory of notes from was this: “On August 2nd, Bryce Harper was off the board to win the NL MVP.”

My first thought was, “Effectively, what’s he now?” I assumed possibly he’d cracked the highest 10 or possibly even the highest 5. Nope, he’s No. 2, at 4/1, behind solely Fernando Tatis Jr., who checks in at 10/11. Harper’s adopted intently by Max Muncy (19/4), with Trea Turner (8/1) and Freddie Freeman (17/2) following behind.

An hour or so later, a tweet from @MLBonFOX cycled via my Twitter timeline, with Harper’s face proper subsequent to Tatis, flanked by Muncy, Turner and Freeman. Oh, after which there’s this, from MLB’s official Twitter account …

MORE: Is Freddie Freeman a Corridor of Famer? He might be, however there’s work to do.

Yep, the Harper hype practice is pulling away from the station, it appears. 

Right here’s the factor: It’s not that Harper is an in depth second, however he’s nonetheless second. And Tatis is on the IL (once more) with a shoulder harm. He’s alleged to be again comparatively quickly (matter of days, not weeks), however he’s already missed 27 of the Padres’ 114 video games this season. May Harper really sneak into this race and snag his second NL MVP award? This one, ought to he pull it off, wouldn’t be almost as dominating as his 2015 win, when he led the NL in homers (42) and bWAR (9.7) for the Nationals and swept all 30 first-place votes. 

Harper wasn’t on the board actually every week in the past, however now he’s second on the listing of betting favorites? So, um, what has he executed these days? In eight August video games, he’s batted .367 with a 1.390 OPS and 4 homers in eight video games. The run moved him over the three/4/5 plateaus — .300 common, .400 on-base share and .500 slugging share — at .302/.413/.570. Vladimir Guerrero Jr. is the one different participant presently over these benchmarks this season, however he’s within the AL, clearly. It’s not essentially unusual (26 gamers have completed within the 3/4/5 membership since 2015) but it surely’s nonetheless spectacular. 

Extra importantly, in all probability, to his MVP odds, is that the Phillies haven’t misplaced in August. Mix that with the Mets in free-fall mode, and Harper’s Phillies have gone from 4 1/2 video games out of first within the NL East on the finish of July to 2 video games up heading into Tuesday’s contest. 

However ought to a profitable streak like that basically affect the MVP race — a person award — a lot? It’s at this level that I’ll say: Bear in mind, these are betting odds. As in, odds to induce folks to guess on issues. The oddsmakers at and @FOXBet don’t really vote for the award, in fact. 

Now, let’s speak about Tatis, who continues to be the favourite however continues to be on the IL. What’s the tipping level, the minimal variety of video games performed wanted to win an MVP award? There isn’t a official minimal, in fact. Clayton Kershaw received the NL award as a beginning pitcher in 2015, when he was dominating in his 27 outings. However realistically, what’s the brink for a place participant corresponding to Tatis? 

Let’s say he performs 40 of his membership’s ultimate 48 video games this season, which feels doable. That will get him to 127 video games. Since MLB expanded to a 162-game schedule in 1961, solely three gamers have received the MVP award with 127 or fewer video games performed (in a non-strike, non-pandemic 12 months): Mickey Mantle in 1962, Willie Stargell in 1979 and George Brett in 1980. 

Mantle performed 123 video games and received going away in 1962, ending with a .321 common 30 dwelling runs and 89 RBIs. He wasn’t almost as wholesome or productive as he was in 1961 (54 homers, 128 RBIs), however that was the 12 months Roger Maris broke Babe Ruth’s document. Not that WAR was a factor again then, however he was at 6.0 and no person else topped 6.2 in 1962. Tremendous alternative.

Stargell shared the 1979 award with Keith Hernandez; he had 10 first-place votes to Hernandez’s 4, however each completed with 216 factors. How unfold out was the voting that 12 months? Eight totally different gamers acquired first-place votes. Stargell hit 32 dwelling runs in his 126 video games, ending with 82 RBIs and a .287 batting common because the Pirates received the NL East with 98 Ws and went on to win the World Sequence. Hernandez, however, performed 161 video games, batted .344 and had 105 RBIs regardless of simply 11 dwelling runs. 

Brett was unbelievable in 1980, batting .390 and ending with extra RBIs (118) than video games performed (117), with 24 homers and 15 stolen bases. He acquired 17 of the 28 first-place votes and received the award comfortably over Reggie Jackson and his 41 homers in 143 video games.

Tatis’ case is extra like Brett’s than Mantle’s or Stargell’s. He’s having an unbelievable season when he’s been on the sector. Regardless of lacking all these video games, he nonetheless leads the NL with 31 dwelling runs — Kyle Schwarber is in second place with 25, however he was traded to the Crimson Sox — and he nonetheless leads the NL in stolen bases, with 23. 

So, yeah. Very particular. 

For argument’s sake, let’s evaluate the seasons of Tatis, Harper and Muncy, the highest 5 contenders in accordance with these specific oddsmakers.

Tatis 87 G .292/.373/.651 31 HR 70 RBI 23 SB 180 OPS+ 5.1 bWAR
Harper 91 G .302/.413/.570 20 HR 45 RBI 12 SB 168 OPS+ 3.4 bWAR
Muncy 95 G .275/.408/.543 22 HR 64 RBI 2 SB 159 OPS+ 5.2 bWAR
Turner 99 G .321/.370/.518 18 HR 49 RBI 22 SB 145 OPS+ 4.1 bWAR
Freeman 111 G .294/.394/.504 24 HR 63 RBI 6 SB 131 OPS+ 3.0 bWAR

Regardless of the fewest video games on the listing — it does matter that everybody else right here apart from Freeman has missed not less than 10 video games — Tatis nonetheless leads within the counting stats (HR/RBI/SB) and is a shade behind Muncy in bWAR, one other cumulative stat. He’s tops within the NL in FanGraphs’ WAR calculation, at 4.5 simply forward of Muncy and Turner, who’re each at 4.3. It needs to be famous that such a small hole in WAR is basically no hole in any respect. 

The most important factor that jumps out about Harper’s stat line is the low RBI whole. He’s been within the 3-hole 76 instances this 12 months and hit cleanup 14 instances (he entered the sport as a pinch-hitter within the No. 8 spot the opposite sport). For one factor, 18 of his 20 homers have been with the bases empty, however he additionally should not be doing effectively in clutch conditions, proper? Incorrect. 

Harper’s batting .317 with a .455 on-base share with runners in scoring place this 12 months. He simply hasn’t had many alternatives. Regardless of taking part in in 91 video games, Harper’s stepped to the plate with RISP in solely 50 video games this 12 months, with 77 whole plate appearances. That’s tied for 164th within the bigs, regardless of being one hundred and fifth within the bigs in total plate appearances. When he’s had the prospect, he has 19 hits, 14 walks and 22 RBIs. 

Harper has these 76 begins within the No. 3 spot within the lineup, however no different Phillies participant has been in a single spot within the order greater than 43 video games. Listed here are the PAs with RISP for different Phillies: Rhys Hoskins (119), Alec Bohm (106), Andrew McCutchen (105), J.T. Realmuto (96). 

I should not have an official vote for the NL MVP this 12 months (I’ve an NL Cy Younger vote) so I can’t declare to know precisely what every of the 30 voters are pondering. However I really feel assured saying this: Except Tatis reinjures his shoulder and solely performs a handful extra video games through the common season, and until Harper hits .367 the remainder of the 12 months, or Muncy turns up the facility a number of notches or Turner carries his new workforce previous the Giants within the NL West with a monster end, the award goes to Tatis. 

Right here’s what I do know for positive, although: If all 5 of those guys keep wholesome, the race will likely be enjoyable to observe and talk about.

Leave a reply